Blog

· By Thesisroom

Updated

APA vs MLA vs Chicago: How Each Formats a Journal Reference

How APA 7, MLA 9 and Chicago author-date format a journal reference and its in-text citation, with sourced examples and six steps for converting a thesis reference list.

A silver pen lies across an open book in warm light, with a stack of books blurred behind it
Photo by Dewang Gupta on Unsplash

Use the style your university or department names, then format every reference by that style’s own pattern. APA 7, MLA 9 and Chicago author-date list the same kind of source differently: Purdue’s APA journal article page puts the year in parentheses after the author, MLA’s in-text page shows citations with no year, and the Monash Chicago 18th author-date guide puts the year after the author with no parentheses.

How do APA 7, MLA 9 and Chicago author-date format a journal reference?

Each style sets its own rules for the list as a whole and for every element inside an entry. The table puts the three side by side, using what the Purdue pages and the two university guides state, or show in their examples. This table covers journal articles only; books and web pages have their own entries in the same guides.

What you setAPA 7MLA 9Chicago 18th, author-date
Title of the listReferences, bold and centeredWorks Cited, centeredWorks Cited or References
OrderAlphabetical by the first author’s last nameAlphabetical by the first item, usually the author’s last nameAlphabetical by last name, then by date for the same author
IndentHanging indent of one-half inchHanging indent of 0.5 inchHanging indent, per the Monash reference list page
YearIn parentheses right after the authorLater in the entry, after the volume and issueRight after the author, no parentheses
Article titleSentence case, no quotation marksQuotation marks, title caseQuotation marks, title case in the examples
Journal titleItalic title case, volume italicItalicsItalics
DOIAfter the page numbers; if there is none and you read it online, the URLA DOI if you have one, otherwise a URL with the http prefix removedA doi.org link at the end

The entries below are copied from the sources, so each one shows a different article. The MLA entry is from Purdue’s MLA in-text page. Compare the position of the year, the style of the title and the ending.

  • APA 7: Baniya, S., & Weech, S. (2019). Data and experience design: Negotiating community-oriented digital research with service-learning. Purdue Journal of Service-Learning and International Engagement, 6(1), 11–16. https://doi.org/10.5703/1288284316979
  • MLA 9: Best, David, and Sharon Marcus. “Surface Reading: An Introduction.” Representations, vol. 108, no. 1, Fall 2009, pp. 1-21. JSTOR, doi:10.1525/rep.2009.108.1.1
  • Chicago 18th author-date: Glass, Jennifer, and Philip Levchak. 2014. “Red States, Blue States, and Divorce: Understanding the Impact of Conservative Protestantism on Regional Variation in Divorce Rates.” American Journal of Sociology 119 (4): 1002–46. https://doi.org/10.1086/674703.

The Chicago entry inverts only the first author’s name, and gives the page range of the whole article, according to the Monash guide. The University of Vermont guide gives the same year-after-author pattern.

How does each style cite a source in the text?

APA and Chicago keep the year in the citation, and MLA does not. The three forms below come straight from the sources.

  1. APA 7: (Jones, 1998). With a direct quote, add the page: (Jones, 1998, p. 199). The Purdue APA in-text page says to include the page number when you quote directly or borrow from another work.
  2. MLA 9: (Wordsworth 263). When you give a page number, it sits in the parentheses and not in the sentence, and the first word of the citation must match the first item in the works cited entry.
  3. Chicago author-date: (Stern 2011, 355). Note there is no comma between author and year, unlike APA.

For two or more authors the patterns shift. MLA gives (Best and Marcus 9) for two authors and (Franck et al. 327) for three or more. The Monash guide shows (Hayden and Wright 1976, 925) and (Gmuca et al. 2015, 162).

Which style should your thesis use?

Use the style your university, department or supervisor names. If the thesis regulations name none, ask your supervisor and keep the answer in writing, and keep one style across the whole list and every in-text citation.

Check the edition too. Both Chicago guides above cover the 18th edition, so confirm which Chicago edition your department uses before you copy their patterns. Chicago also has a second system, notes and bibliography, which the University of Vermont guide mentions alongside author-date. If your department asks for footnotes, the Chicago column of this table does not apply.

How do you convert a reference list from one style to another?

Work from the list-level rules down to single entries, then check that the text still points to the right entry.

  1. Confirm the style and edition in writing (APA 7th, MLA 9th, or the Chicago edition your department uses).
  2. Fix the list rules first: the title of the list, alphabetical order and the hanging indent where the style states one.
  3. Rework one entry at a time with the table above: move the year, rewrite the article title in the style’s case, and put the DOI in the form the style wants. Our post on what a DOI in a reference looks like shows its parts.
  4. Rewrite every in-text citation. MLA drops the year, APA and Chicago keep it, and APA keeps “p.” before a page number while MLA and Chicago give the number alone.
  5. Match the text and the list in both directions: every in-text citation has an entry, and every entry is cited. MLA’s rule that the first word of the citation matches the first word of the entry is a good test in any style.
  6. Check that each reference exists. A correctly formatted entry says nothing about that, and the post on how to verify references walks the manual checks. Paste the finished list into the free Citation Check to see which ones it cannot find.

For the whole pre-submission audit of a list, see thesis defense reference list checking. If you are unsure whether your thesis needs a reference list or a bibliography, read bibliography vs reference list.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better for a thesis: APA, MLA or Chicago?None is better in general. Use the style your university, department or supervisor requires, and confirm the edition. If the regulations do not name a style, ask your supervisor before you format anything.
Does MLA put the year in the in-text citation?No. MLA uses the author and the page number, for example (Wordsworth 263), according to [Purdue OWL](https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/mla_style/mla_formatting_and_style_guide/mla_in_text_citations_the_basics.html). The year appears inside the works cited entry instead.
Where does the year go in Chicago author-date?In the reference list it follows the author with no parentheses. In the text it follows the author and comes before the page, as in (Stern 2011, 355), per the Monash guide.
When does APA need a page number in the text?For direct quotes and borrowed material, as in (Jones, 1998, p. 199). A paraphrase may leave the page number out, according to Purdue OWL’s APA in-text page.
Should I include the DOI in my references?In APA, Purdue says to include the DOI after the page numbers if the article has one. In MLA, use a DOI if you have one, otherwise a URL. The Monash Chicago guide ends the entry with a DOI written as a doi.org link.

Sources

How this guide was made: Thesisroom drafted this guide with the help of AI writing tools. Every fact, figure and source in this post was checked against its original source before publishing.