Blog

· By Thesisroom

Updated

How to Write a Discussion Chapter: 8 Steps and a Worked Example

Eight steps for a thesis discussion chapter, drawn from university guides, with one invented finding discussed paragraph by paragraph, a table for each kind of result and a checklist to print.

This guide has a printable version: open the printable discussion chapter checklist

Hands with a pen marking a spread of printed pages with tables on a dark wooden table.
Photo by Dimitri Karastelev on Unsplash

How to write a discussion chapter, in short: take each main finding in turn and say what it means for your research questions and how it compares with the literature you reviewed. Then explain any unexpected result and say what the findings imply, as Sheffield Hallam University’s guide sets out. The University of Southampton’s dissertation guide puts the test in one line: “What do we now know that we didn’t before?”

The rules differ between universities, and between theses with a separate discussion chapter and those with one combined “results and discussion” chapter. Check your own department’s guidance first. What follows is the common ground across named university guides, with a worked example you can copy the shape of.

What does a discussion chapter do in a thesis?

A discussion chapter interprets your findings: it explains what they mean, not what they were. Sheffield Hallam’s guide says its purpose is “to interpret your findings, discuss their reliability,” and explain how your research added to understanding of the problem.

Victoria University of Wellington lists five jobs for a standard discussion chapter:

  • Interpret: say what your results mean.
  • Compare: set your results against previous studies.
  • Evaluate: judge the importance of your research.
  • Limit: highlight the limitations of your research.
  • Look ahead: point out questions or avenues for future research.

The results chapter is the factual account. Southampton’s guide describes the discussion as the place that relates findings to the literature and answers your research questions. Sheffield Hallam adds that future directions “could also be included in your conclusion”, so agree with your supervisor where that part sits.

Does the discussion have to be a separate chapter?

No. Some theses keep results and discussion apart, others combine them, and the choice depends on your discipline and department. Here is what four university guides say.

University guideWhat it says about structure and placementStructure it suggests
SouthamptonIn scientific writing and many other subjects, results come as a distinct chapter followed by a discrete discussion chapter. Some dissertations combine both in one chapter.Says “there is no single way to structure your discussion chapter.” Mirror your results chapter where possible.
Victoria University of WellingtonIn some disciplines the discussion may be integrated with the results. Your supervisor may advise a discussion section at the end of many chapters.Five jobs: interpret, compare, evaluate, limit, look ahead.
WestminsterThe discussion chapter differs “according to the discipline and structure” of your dissertation.It “can be structured according to the objectives you laid out in the introduction.”
Sheffield HallamNotes that the structure of discussion sections “can vary”.Major findings, research questions, literature, unexpected findings, alternative interpretations, limitations, future directions.

If you write a combined chapter, Southampton’s guide gives two options. Keep results and discussion as separate sections within the chapter, or present a subset of results, discuss it, then move to the next subset. The steps below apply either way. For where the discussion sits among the other chapters, see the chapter map in our guide to PhD thesis structure.

How should a discussion chapter be structured?

Open with your main findings, then give one section to each research question or theme, then cover limitations, implications and future research. That is close to the order in Sheffield Hallam’s guide, and it is a sensible default until your department says otherwise.

A workable outline:

  1. Opening: restate the research problem in a sentence or two, then your principal findings.
  2. One section per research question, objective or theme, in the same order as your results chapter.
  3. Inside each section: the finding, what it means, how it sits against the literature, and any unexpected part.
  4. Limitations that the findings revealed.
  5. Implications for theory and for practice.
  6. Future research, kept brief.

Docherty and Smith’s BMJ editorial, written for journal papers, proposes a similar order: principal findings, strengths and weaknesses, comparison with other studies, meaning and implications, then unanswered questions. They also criticize discussions written as “extensive text without subheadings”. In a thesis chapter, subheadings that name each research question or theme help an examiner find your answer.

How to write a discussion chapter in 8 steps

Work from your results chapter and your literature review open side by side. Each step below produces a piece of the chapter.

  1. List each research question with the finding that answers it. Write one line per question: the question, then the finding in plain words. Westminster’s guide says the discussion answers the research question, or says whether the hypothesis was supported. A question with no line next to it is a gap to fix now.
  2. Put your principal findings first. Hess, writing about journal research papers in Respiratory Care, says the discussion “should begin with a statement of the major findings” in its very first paragraph. Sheffield Hallam also advises putting your most important findings first.
  3. Bring back the literature you reviewed. Southampton’s guide says the discussion “should return to the relevant literature” from your literature review. For each finding, pull the two or three studies it agrees or disagrees with. If those studies are not in your review, check whether the review needs them, using our guide on how to write a literature review for a thesis.
  4. Write each finding as a discussion cycle. Southampton describes a three-part cycle: a topic sentence states the focus, a main body analyzes it with the literature, and an evaluative close says what it means for the research question. The University of Manchester’s Academic Phrasebank says discussions are built around a “statement of result” and often run as “a series of discussion cycles”. Oxford Lifelong Learning describes longer discussion sections the same way.
  5. Explain unexpected results and weigh other readings. Southampton’s guide says not to ignore data that does not meet your expectations. Sheffield Hallam says to state the unexpected finding first, then offer your interpretation of why it happened. Then give the alternative explanations, as both Sheffield Hallam and Hess advise, and say why you prefer yours.
  6. Read the findings through your theoretical framework. The USC Libraries guide, written for social science research papers, suggests linking findings “to the literature, then to theory, then to practice”. If your framework vanished after the literature review, our guide on linking a theoretical framework to analysis shows how to bring it back.
  7. Say what the findings mean and where they stop. Answer “So what?”, the question Southampton’s guide calls vital, for theory and for practice. Name the limitations that emerged after analysis, which Southampton separates from the method limits you named before collecting data, using the template in our guide on how to write limitations of a study. Keep future research brief: Sheffield Hallam says “you’re not writing a proposal for this further research”.
  8. Revise the whole chapter against the overclaiming list. Cut any sentence that only repeats a result. Check that no new results appear, which USC rules out, and that no interpretation goes “beyond what is supported by the data” (Hess). If you have a full draft, Thesisroom’s Argument Map reads the whole thesis and shows research questions that are stated but never answered, quoting your own passages.

The implications you write in step 7 are close to the contribution claim examiners probe in a viva. Our guide to the contribution to knowledge viva question shows how to size that claim so it holds.

What does a discussion paragraph look like? A worked example

This example is invented for illustration. The study, the finding and the cited works are made up, and “Study A” and “Study B” stand in for real sources from your own literature review.

The setting: a Master’s thesis in education, with interviews with twelve early-career teachers in two secondary schools. Research question 2 asks how early-career teachers decide which mentor feedback to act on.

Paragraph 1: restate the finding against the question

The second research question asked how early-career teachers decide which mentor feedback to act on. The clearest pattern across the twelve interviews was timing. Teachers acted on comments about a lesson they would teach again that week, and set aside comments on lessons they would not repeat soon.

This is the topic sentence of the cycle. It names the question, then the finding, with no statistics or long quotes repeated from the results chapter.

Paragraph 2: compare with the literature

This supports Study A’s argument that feedback is used when the learner has a near chance to apply it. It sits less easily with Study B, which linked teachers’ use of feedback to how often mentors gave it. In this study, the teachers who received the most comments did not report using more of them.

One agreement, one disagreement, and the exact point of difference. Manchester’s Phrasebank lists both moves: supporting and contradicting previous findings.

Paragraph 3: explain the unexpected part and weigh other readings

The weak link with feedback volume was not expected. One reading is that the chance to reapply matters more than the amount of feedback. A second is structural: both schools teach the same lesson to parallel classes, so the chance to reapply was built into the timetable. The first reading is preferred, because several teachers described the same rule for after-school clubs, which are not taught in parallel.

The unexpected result is stated first, then two explanations, then a reason to prefer one. Docherty and Smith’s advice applies here too: if you do not know why your result differs from others, do not pretend you do.

Paragraph 4: name the limit this finding revealed

Both schools used the same timetable model, so this pattern may not hold where lessons are rarely repeated. That limit only became visible once the interviews were analyzed.

This is a limit that emerged after analysis, the kind Southampton places in the discussion, tied to one finding.

Paragraph 5: implications and the next study

For mentoring programs, the finding suggests timing comments to the next repeat of a lesson rather than adding more of them. For the field, it narrows Study B’s claim: how often feedback arrives may matter less than whether there is a near chance to use it. A study in schools without parallel classes would test which reading holds.

This answers “So what?” for practice and for theory, then gives one brief, testable next step.

What should you do with each kind of result?

Each kind of result needs a different move. Use this table when you plan each section of the chapter.

Kind of resultWhat to writeSource for the move
Answers the research question as expectedState how it answers the question, then what it adds to the literature.Westminster, Sheffield Hallam
Agrees with earlier studiesName the studies and the point of agreement, then what your study adds.Hess, Manchester Phrasebank
Conflicts with earlier studiesShow the exact difference and possible reasons. Do not assume your result is right and theirs wrong.Docherty and Smith
UnexpectedState it first, then your interpretation, then how it relates to the whole study.Sheffield Hallam, USC
Not statistically significantInterpret it rather than hide it. Sheffield Hallam notes that “we can still learn from non-significant research findings.”Sheffield Hallam
Statistically significant but possibly not meaningfulSay whether the difference is meaningful, not only measurable.Hess
A question your findings could not answerSay which question and why, then what a later study would need.Sheffield Hallam

What should not be included in a discussion chapter?

Leave out new results, repeated results and claims your data cannot carry. Named guides warn against these:

  • New results: USC’s guide says “Do not introduce new results in the discussion section.”
  • Repeated results: Sheffield Hallam’s guide says “Don’t simply repeat your results section.”
  • Overinterpretation: Hess, writing about journal papers, warns against interpretation that goes beyond the data, and against words such as “novel”, “the first study” and “impressive” about your own work.
  • Apology: Sheffield Hallam advises “Avoid being apologetic or too critical” about your limitations.
  • Ignored awkward data: Southampton says leaving out data that does not fit your expectations “undermines your credibility as a researcher”.
  • Easy recommendations: USC says not to offer recommendations “which could have been easily addressed within the study.”

Printable discussion chapter checklist

Tick each item against your draft before you send the chapter to your supervisor.

  • I checked my department’s rule on a separate or combined results and discussion chapter.
  • The opening paragraph restates the research problem and states my principal findings.
  • Every research question or hypothesis has a section that answers it explicitly.
  • The sections follow the same order as my results chapter.
  • Each section has a topic sentence, an analysis and an evaluative close.
  • Each main finding is compared with named studies from my literature review.
  • I said where my findings agree with earlier studies and where they conflict.
  • Every unexpected result is stated, interpreted and related to the whole study.
  • I gave alternative explanations and said why I prefer mine.
  • My theoretical framework is used to interpret the findings.
  • Non-significant results are interpreted, not hidden.
  • Limitations that emerged after analysis are named, without apology.
  • The chapter answers “So what?” for theory and for practice.
  • Future research is brief and does not include anything this study could have done.
  • No new results appear in the chapter.
  • No sentence only repeats a result from the results chapter.
  • No claim goes beyond what my data support.
  • I removed “novel”, “the first study” and “impressive” about my own work.
  • My supervisor agreed where the future directions part belongs.

Frequently asked questions

How do I start my discussion chapter?Start with a short paragraph that restates the research problem and states your major findings. Hess, writing about journal papers, puts the major findings in the very first paragraph, and Sheffield Hallam’s guide suggests the opening can also restate the problem and the methods you used. Then move to your first research question.
What is the format of a discussion chapter?Discussion chapters often run as a series of cycles, one per finding or theme. Each cycle states a result, interprets it, compares it with earlier studies, and says what it means. The University of Manchester’s Academic Phrasebank and Oxford Lifelong Learning both describe discussion sections built from these cycles.
Can I organize the discussion by theme instead of by research question?Yes, if it suits your study. Southampton’s guide says there is no single way to structure the discussion and suggests matching your results chapter where possible. Westminster’s guide suggests structuring it by the objectives in your introduction. Whatever you choose, each research question still needs an explicit answer.
Should limitations go in the discussion chapter?Often, yes. Southampton’s guide says it is common to have limitations in the discussion chapter, and it separates method limitations, identified before the research, from discussion limitations, which emerge after analysis. Sheffield Hallam asks you to say how each one affects your interpretation, without being apologetic. Check whether your department also wants a separate limitations section.
What tense should I use in a discussion chapter?Mostly the present tense. USC’s guide recommends using the same verb tense as your introduction, the present. Oxford Lifelong Learning notes that a key point in the present tense, such as “We therefore conclude that”, reads as stronger than a past passive such as “It is therefore argued that”. Check your department’s style guide too.
What is the difference between the results and the discussion?The results chapter reports what you found, in a factual way. The discussion explains what those findings mean, relates them to the literature and answers your research questions. Southampton’s guide draws exactly this line, and Sheffield Hallam warns against a discussion that simply repeats the results.

Sources

How this guide was made: Thesisroom drafted this guide with the help of AI writing tools. Every fact, figure and source in this post was checked against its original source before publishing.