Blog

· By Thesisroom

Updated

Questions to Ask at the End of Your Viva (The Ones That Land Well)

Most vivas end with the chair asking if you have anything to add. Here are questions to ask at the end of a viva that land well, and the ones that read badly no matter how they are phrased.

A hand writing with a black pen in an open notebook beside a red book, near a sunlit window.

The moment nobody rehearses for

Most vivas end with the chair asking, “Do you have anything else you would like to add, or any questions for the panel?” Nearly every candidate hears this. Nearly none prepare for it. The result is either an uncomfortable “no thank you” or a scramble to say something meaningful under pressure.

Questions to ask at the end of a viva is a small preparation task with a real payoff. The questions you choose signal how you have thought about the work, how you see it going forward, and how you handle a scholarly conversation with more senior researchers. This piece walks the questions that land well, the ones that land badly, and the two you should always be ready with.

Questions that land well

Five specific questions consistently read well in vivas across UK, US, and European systems.

A publication question. “Do you have suggestions on which of the chapters would be strongest for journal submission first?” This shows the panel that you are already thinking about post-thesis work and invites their expertise. Panels usually enjoy the question because it puts them in mentor role rather than examiner role.

A next-study question. “You mentioned during the questioning that X would be a natural next study. Do you have thoughts on where the strongest follow-up work is happening in the field?” This shows engagement with the wider research programme. Kiley (2009) frames this awareness as one of the threshold concepts panels test for.

A reading recommendation question. “Are there any specific authors or papers you think I should read that would strengthen the framing of this work?” This is a genuine invitation for the panel to share their expertise. An examiner may well have a recommendation.

A specific-chapter feedback question. “You raised a concern about chapter four’s discussion of X. Beyond the changes we discussed, is there a specific angle you think I should develop more fully?” This shows that you were listening carefully during the viva and treats the feedback as constructive.

A methodology-extension question. “If I were to develop this into a larger study, do you have thoughts on which methodological extension would be most valuable?” This is close to the next-study question but focused on method rather than topic.

Questions that land badly

Three specific patterns consistently read badly.

Outcome-fishing questions. “How do you think it went?” or “Do you think I passed?” put the panel in an awkward position. They cannot answer honestly before deliberation, and asking implies you are uncertain about your own performance. Trafford and Leshem (2008) note that these questions are among the most common closing-question mistakes.

Defensive questions. “Was my methodology really that weak?” or “Do you still think X was a problem?” turn the closing into a re-examination of what has already been discussed. The viva conversation is over; the deliberation is next. Do not reopen closed threads.

Fishing-for-validation questions. “Do you think my contribution is significant?” is a version of outcome-fishing. Panels cannot give this validation before deliberation, and asking shifts the tone. Trust the substantive work you did in the room to have made the case.

The two questions to prepare in advance

Two questions are worth preparing to have ready, so you can pick the fitting one on the day.

The publication question. Phrased for your situation: “Given the panel’s reading of the work, which chapter would you suggest submitting first as a journal article, and to which journal?” Adjust based on what came up during the viva. This is close to universally welcome.

The next-study question. “You raised questions during the viva about X. In your view, what would be the strongest next study to run on X?” This treats the viva as the beginning of a conversation, not the end.

Have both ready. Deliver the one that fits the way the viva went.

What if you genuinely have no questions

The honest answer is fine. “Thank you, I think we have covered what I hoped to discuss. I appreciate the depth of your reading.” This closes the viva politely without inventing something. Panels prefer a clean close to a forced question.

The one thing not to do is apologise or minimise. “No, sorry, I do not have anything.” reads defensively. A composed “no thank you” reads as confident.

The other invitation nobody expects

Some panels also invite a closing statement: “Is there anything else you would like the panel to consider before we deliberate?” This is a different moment from the questions moment, and it deserves a specific preparation.

The move that lands well is a one-sentence restatement of your contribution, matched to what came up during the viva. “The core contribution I hope the panel takes away is X, especially in light of your questions on Y.” This closes the case on your terms.

The move that lands badly is a defensive plea. “I hope you will consider that I was under time pressure” or “I want to explain again why I did not include Z” reopens closed conversations. Deliver the sentence you wrote before the day and stop.

What Thesisroom does with this

Thesisroom’s defense practice generates rehearsal questions from your thesis, but it also generates the closing-statement and closing-question moments as part of a full-length mock viva. Rehearsing the last five minutes of the viva against your own text prepares you for the exact prompts panels use.

The full method treats the whole viva as one continuous conversation, opening through close, so the rehearsal covers the moments that are easy not to plan for.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to ask a question at the end of my viva?

No. Panels invite a question but do not require one. Declining politely (“Thank you, I think we have covered what I hoped to discuss”) is a valid close. What matters is that you decline composed rather than defensively.

What is the best question to ask?

A publication question tends to land universally well. “Which chapter would you suggest submitting first as a journal article, and to which journal?” Panels enjoy the mentor role and usually have specific suggestions.

Can I ask about corrections?

Not before the panel has deliberated. Asking “what corrections do you think I will need?” reads as outcome-fishing. Wait for the outcome; discuss corrections at the debrief that follows deliberation.

Should I thank the panel?

Yes, briefly. A single sentence of thanks for their reading is normal and expected. Extended thanks that stretch to a paragraph reads as filler. Keep it short and move on.

What if I want to add something I forgot?

Add it clearly and briefly. “One thing I would like to add on point X, which we did not have time to discuss fully...” This is legitimate use of the closing moment. Keep it to two sentences.

How does Thesisroom rehearse the closing moment?

Defense Practice runs full-length mock vivas that include the closing question and closing statement. Rehearsing these against your own text prepares you for the specific prompts panels use in the last five minutes.

One takeaway before you close this tab

Prepare one publication question and one next-study question, and be ready to decline politely if neither fits. Do not ask outcome-fishing questions, do not reopen closed threads, and do not stretch thanks into filler. When you want the full viva rehearsed end to end, Thesisroom’s defense practice covers the opening through the close.

References

Kiley, M. (2009). Identifying threshold concepts and proposing strategies to support doctoral candidates. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 46(3), 293-304.

Trafford, V., & Leshem, S. (2008). Stepping Stones to Achieving your Doctorate. Open University Press.

viva · land · end · close · closing