Blog

· By Thesisroom

Synthesis Matrix for a Literature Review: Columns, Example and Template

What a synthesis matrix is, which columns suit a thematic, methodological or question-led review, how to fill and read it, and how one column becomes a paragraph.

This guide has a printable version: open the printable synthesis matrix template

Open notebook filled with handwritten notes beside loose annotated pages and a yellow sticky note on a desk
Photo by Yen Vu - 烟雨 on Unsplash

A synthesis matrix (also called a literature review matrix) is a table that lines up your sources against the themes of your literature review. NC State University’s writing tutors call it “a chart that allows a researcher to sort and categorize the different arguments presented on an issue” (NC State handout). It lets you compare what every source says about one theme at a glance.

Below you will find how a synthesis matrix differs from similar tables, which columns suit three kinds of review, and what goes in a cell. Then an invented worked example shows how to read the grid for agreement, conflict and gaps, and how one column becomes one paragraph. A printable template is at the end.

What is a synthesis matrix?

A synthesis matrix is a grid with one source per row and one theme, variable or question per column. Each cell holds a short note on what that source says about that theme. North Shore Community College’s library calls it a table that lets you arrange sources by topic and “essentially creates an outline for your paper” (North Shore Community College).

The same tool goes by several names, including literature review matrix and review matrix. The University of Toledo’s library says an evidence table is “Sometimes called a literature matrix, evaluation table, or synthesis table” (University of Toledo Libraries).

Guides also disagree on which way round the grid goes. The NC State handout and Saint Mary’s University of Minnesota put sources across the top and themes down the side (Saint Mary’s University of Minnesota). This guide uses sources as rows and themes as columns, so each new source you read becomes a new row. Either way works if you stay consistent.

How is a synthesis matrix different from an annotated bibliography, a summary table and an outline?

The difference is what each one is organized around. An annotated bibliography is organized by source, a summary table by study features, an outline by section, and a synthesis matrix by theme across sources.

ToolOrganized byOne entry holdsWhat it helps you do
Annotated bibliographySource, usually alphabeticalA summary and evaluation of one sourceJudge each source on its own
Summary tableSource, with columns for study featuresDesign, sample, findings of one studyCompare how studies were done
Synthesis matrixSource and theme togetherWhat one source says about one themeSee agreement, conflict and gaps per theme
Literature review outlineChapter sectionThe claim and sources for one sectionPlan the order of the chapter

Wheaton College’s library draws the first line clearly. In an annotated bibliography, “Each source is listed separately in alphabetical order and is only included once.” In a literature review, sources sit in paragraphs “organized by theme”, and “sources can be repeated” (Wheaton College Library). If you already keep annotations, our guide on how to write an annotated bibliography for a PhD covers that format, and your annotations can feed the matrix cells.

A summary table and a synthesis matrix can be the same file at different stages. The useful test is what your columns hold. If every column is a study feature (author, design, sample, findings), you have a summary table. Once some columns are themes or questions from your own review, the table starts to synthesize.

An outline comes after the matrix. Saint Mary’s says that as you fill the matrix, themes “will start to emerge. You will use these themes to create your headings” (Saint Mary’s University of Minnesota).

Which columns should a synthesis matrix have?

Start with a few fixed columns that identify each source, then add columns that match the kind of review you are writing. Duquesne University’s library says “Every review matrix should have the same first three column headings: (1) authors, title, and journal, (2) publication year, and (3) purpose” (Duquesne University). That is one library’s suggestion: guides differ between universities, and your supervisor or department may prefer another layout.

After those, the columns depend on your review. Three common sets:

Review typeColumns after the fixed onesUse it when
ThematicOne column per theme or debate (for example: effect on outcome, mechanism, who benefits), plus a comments columnYour question breaks into topics that several sources address
MethodologicalDesign, sample and setting, measures, analysis, main finding, stated limits, plus a comments columnStudies disagree and you suspect the methods explain it
By research questionOne column per research question or sub-question, written as a question, plus a comments columnYour thesis has two or more research questions and the review must serve each

For any of these sets, Duquesne suggests three kinds of extra heading: methodological, content-specific and geographical, such as the country where the research was done (Duquesne University). A Stanford teaching activity adds a “method” column because method “is often an overlooked point of divergence between sources” (Stanford University).

The research-question set is offered by James Cook University, whose library links two templates: a literature review matrix by theme and one by question (James Cook University). Saint Mary’s example matrix also writes its themes as questions.

Whichever set you choose, keep a column for your own view. San José State University’s Writing Center splits its matrix into “THEY SAY” columns for what authors report and “I SAY” columns for your own thoughts (San José State University Writing Center). It also says of column headings: “There is no right way to do it.”

One rule from Duquesne saves wasted columns: “If the answer will be the same for every study, it’s generally a bad choice for a column heading.” If your review covers adolescents, an age column tells you nothing (Duquesne University).

How do you build a synthesis matrix, step by step?

Build it while you read, not in advance. Duquesne warns: “Do not try to fully complete a review matrix before reading the articles.”

  1. Write your research question above the grid. Every cell you fill should help answer it. Saint Mary’s advises noting “only the ideas that address your research question”, since only part of a long article may bear on your topic.
  2. Add the fixed columns. Authors, title and journal; year; purpose. If you sort by year, changes in the research over time become visible, which is why Duquesne suggests organizing sources by date.
  3. Add your first theme columns, and leave room. Write the themes you expect, then keep a few blank columns. Saint Mary’s says to “leave some blanks for surprises” for ideas you had not thought of.
  4. Read one source and fill its row. Put a short note in each theme cell the source addresses. Leave a cell empty when the source says nothing on that theme.
  5. Add a column when a new theme appears in two or more sources. In a Walden University Writing Center podcast, a co-host describes the matrix as “a snapshot of your research rather than your research being driven by what is in the matrix already” (Walden University Writing Center).
  6. Fill your comments column for every row. Write what the source is worth to your argument: its strength, its limit, and which theme it matters most to.
  7. Prune before you write. Delete or merge columns where every row says the same thing, and columns that only one source fills unless that emptiness is itself a finding.

A spreadsheet makes steps 5 and 7 easier. Adler University’s library suggests Excel or Google Sheets “so you can sort by column” (Adler University Library). Keep the matrix beside your reference library, and tag sources the same way in both. Our guide on how to organize sources for a PhD covers the tagging side.

What goes in a cell?

A cell holds one short note in your own words, a page number, and nothing else. It should be readable in a few seconds, because you will scan a whole column at once.

  • Paraphrase by default: Write the point in a phrase or one sentence. In the same episode, the other co-host notes that you do not need to put everything you highlighted into the matrix, and that filling it is a chance to practice paraphrasing and summarizing.
  • Quote only exact wording you may use: If the author’s phrasing matters, copy it in quotation marks so you never mistake it for your own words later.
  • Always add a page number: In the NC State sample matrix, each note carries a page number (NC State, hosted by FIU). It saves you reopening the PDF when you write.
  • Use codes where a yes or no will do: Adler suggests that “Many columns can have just a check box or simple yes/no to make sorting easier.” James Cook suggests a column for “a + or - or numerical value” if you score sources as you go.
  • Keep blank and “not found” apart: A blank should mean the source does not address the theme. If the source addresses it and finds nothing, write that, because a null result and a missing topic lead to different paragraphs.

Here is the same cell written three ways, for a source on peer mentoring:

Weak cellWhy it failsBetter cell
Discusses confidenceSays nothing you can compareHigher self-rated confidence after one semester; no comparison group (p. 6)
A full paragraph copied from the abstractToo long to scan, and not your wordsWeekly pairs with third-year students (p. 4)
BlankUnclear: not studied, or studied and found nothing?No effect on validated scale at year end (p. 12)

What does a filled-in synthesis matrix look like?

Here is an invented example for one research question: does peer mentoring build clinical confidence in first-year nursing students? The five sources, their designs and their findings are made up to show the method. They are not real studies.

SourceDesign and settingEffect on confidenceWhat the mentoring involvedWho benefits mostMy comment
Source ASurvey, one nursing schoolHigher self-rated confidence after one semester (p. 6)Weekly pairs with third-year students (p. 4)Self-report only; no comparison group
Source BInterviews, two schoolsStudents describe feeling “less alone on placement” (p. 41)Informal, student-led meetings (p. 38)Students with no prior healthcare work (p. 44)Best account of how mentoring might work
Source CQuasi-experiment with a comparison group, one schoolNo difference on a validated confidence scale at year end (p. 12)Monthly group sessions (p. 8)Strongest design; much lighter mentoring
Source DMixed methods, one schoolHigher scores in the first term; gap closed by year end (p. 9)Weekly pairs, mentors trained (p. 5)First-generation students gained most (p. 14)Suggests the effect may fade
Source ESurvey, three countriesHigher self-rated confidence (p. 22)Not describedCannot compare mentoring formats

This uses the thematic set, with “Design and setting” carried over from the methodological set. That one column turns out to matter most, as the next section shows.

How do you read a synthesis matrix to find agreement, conflict and gaps?

Read down each theme column, not along each row. A row tells you about one source, which your annotations already do. A column tells you what the literature says about one theme.

  1. Mark agreement. Find the cells that point the same way. In the example, Sources A, B and E all report more confidence with mentoring.
  2. Check what the agreeing sources have in common. Look across to the design column. Sources A and E are both self-report surveys, so the agreement is about how students feel, not about a measured change.
  3. Mark conflict, then look for a reason in the other columns. Source C finds no effect. Its row shows a comparison group, a validated scale and monthly group sessions instead of weekly pairs. Measurement and dose are two possible explanations, and Source D’s fading effect adds timing as a third.
  4. Read the blanks. The NC State handout says: “The gaps on your chart could provide clues about the gaps in the current state of knowledge on your topic.” In the example, “Who benefits most” has only two filled cells, and no source tests weekly paired mentoring against a comparison group for a full year.
  5. Check the dates. Sort by year to see whether a conflict is old work against new work, or whether a theme stopped being studied.
  6. Write one sentence per column. State what the column shows: agreement, conflict with a likely reason, or a gap. These sentences become the opening claims of your paragraphs.

A blank cell is a clue, not a proven gap. Search again before you claim one, and use our guide to testing whether a research gap is real before you build a thesis on it.

How do you turn a column into a synthesis paragraph?

Take one column and the sentence you wrote for it in step 6. That sentence opens the paragraph, the cells supply the evidence, and the comments column supplies your judgment.

  1. Open with the claim about the literature, not about one source.
  2. Group the sources that agree and cite them together.
  3. Bring in the conflicting source and give the likely reason from the other columns.
  4. Close on what remains open or what it means for your question.

Here is the “Effect on confidence” column written as one paragraph (the sources are still invented):

Peer mentoring is consistently linked with higher confidence among first-year nursing students, but the link rests mostly on self-report. Two surveys found higher self-rated confidence among mentored students (Source A; Source E), and interviewees described feeling less alone on placement (Source B). The only study with a comparison group and a validated scale found no difference by the end of the year, though it offered monthly group sessions rather than weekly pairs (Source C). A study of weekly pairs found an early gain that faded by year end (Source D), so whether peer mentoring changes measured confidence, and for how long, remains untested.

Notice what the paragraph does with the matrix. Sources A and E sit in one citation because their cells agree. Source C is explained, not just listed, using its design and mentoring cells. The last sentence comes from the blanks and from Source D’s comment.

Each column-paragraph then becomes a section of the chapter. The next step, organizing those sections and writing the whole chapter around your gap, is covered in our guide on how to write a literature review for a thesis. For where that chapter sits in the full thesis and what examiners check in it, see the PhD thesis structure guide.

Printable synthesis matrix template

Put one source per row and one theme per column, with a short note and page number in each cell (leave it blank if the source is silent).

Research question: ______________________________________________

Source (author, year)Design and settingTheme 1: ________Theme 2: ________Theme 3: ________Theme 4: ________My comment

When the grid is full, read down each theme column and fill in one row per theme.

ThemeSources that agreeSources that conflict, and the likely reasonBlank cells: possible gap?My opening claim for this paragraph
Theme 1
Theme 2
Theme 3
Theme 4

Frequently asked questions

Is a literature review matrix the same as a synthesis matrix?Mostly, yes. Adler University’s library labels its synthesis matrix template a “Literature Review Research Matrix”, and the University of Toledo’s library lists literature matrix and synthesis table among the other names for an evidence table. What matters is whether your columns hold themes you can compare across sources.
How many columns should a synthesis matrix have?The guides we read set no number. Start with author, year and purpose, as Duquesne University suggests, then one column per theme, method feature or research question. Drop any column where every source gives the same answer, and add one when a new theme shows up in more than one source.
Should I use Excel or Word for a synthesis matrix?A spreadsheet is easier once you have many sources, because you can sort by column and add columns freely. Adler University’s library suggests Excel or Google Sheets for that reason. A Word table works for a small review, and Saint Mary’s University of Minnesota even suggests taping pages together.
Can I put direct quotes in a synthesis matrix?Yes, but sparingly. Paraphrase by default so the cells are short and already in your words. When the author’s exact wording matters, copy it in quotation marks with the page number, so you never confuse a quote with your own note when you write the chapter.
When should I start a synthesis matrix?Start it as soon as you begin reading in depth, with the themes you expect and a few blank columns. Duquesne University advises against completing the matrix before reading the articles, and Saint Mary’s suggests taking brief notes as you research to insert into the cells.
What do empty cells in a synthesis matrix mean?An empty cell means that source does not address that theme. A column with many empty cells may point to a gap, as NC State’s handout notes, but search again before you claim it. Write “studied, no effect” when a source tested a theme and found nothing, so it is not mistaken for a blank.

Sources

How this guide was made: Thesisroom drafted this guide with the help of AI writing tools. Every fact, figure and source in this post was checked against its original source before publishing.