Blog

· By Thesisroom

Updated

Systematic Review vs Literature Review: Which One Your Thesis Needs

How a systematic review differs from a literature review, the structured middle option many master's students use, PROSPERO rules, and method wording to adapt.

Two students at a table leafing through thick books beside loose printed pages, faces out of frame
Photo by Sarah Noltner on Unsplash

Systematic review vs literature review comes down to method, not length. A literature review selects and synthesises sources to build an argument. A systematic review follows a protocol written before the search, with documented searches, explicit inclusion criteria and a record of every study screened out, so another researcher could repeat it. Your handbook and supervisor decide which one your thesis needs, and many master’s projects can use a defined middle option.

Systematic review vs literature review: the actual difference

The short answer: a literature review argues, a systematic review audits. The University of Derby’s library guide puts it plainly. A systematic review is “focused on one question”. A narrative review is “not limited to focussing on one particular question within a topic” (University of Derby).

Oregon Health and Science University’s library sets the two side by side. A systematic review has a “comprehensive, documented search strategy”, and its “methods are documented and reproducible”. A narrative review has “no detailed search strategy” and its methods are “often insufficiently documented for replication” (OHSU Library).

DimensionLiterature (narrative) reviewSystematic review
QuestionBroad, can be an overview of a topicOne focused question, fixed in advance
ProtocolNoneWritten before searching
SearchSelective, judgement-ledComprehensive and documented
SelectionCriteria rarely statedExplicit inclusion and exclusion criteria
Quality appraisalMay not be includedEach study assessed
ReportingYour own structureA reporting guideline such as PRISMA 2020
Can someone repeat itUsually notThat is the point

Both still need real sources, critical reading rather than summary, and a reference list an examiner can trace. If you are still deciding what to keep, our guide to how to evaluate sources for a literature review gives a five-filter method that works for either kind.

The middle option most master’s students actually need

Between the two sits a review that borrows systematic methods without claiming to be a full systematic review. Grant and Booth’s typology of 14 review types calls it a “systematized review”. They note these “are typically conducted as a postgraduate student assignment”, without the resources a full systematic review needs (Grant and Booth, 2009).

University libraries describe it under several names:

  • Systematic literature review: Oxford’s Bodleian Libraries define it as a review that “draws upon systematic review methods to ensure it is more rigorous than a traditional literature review” (Bodleian Libraries).
  • Systematised or structured literature review: the University of Lincoln’s guide is written “for students undertaking a systematised literature review” as a dissertation. It differs from a narrative review “by including a transparent methodology” (University of Lincoln).

The Bodleian guide gives the practical reason this option exists. “Full systematic reviews usually take a minimum of 12 months to complete, and require a team of at least 2 people.” It adds that this “is generally not feasible for a master’s-level or medical student project” (Bodleian Libraries).

One line from Derby is worth keeping in your head while you write. Searching carefully “doesn’t mean you’re doing a systematic review, it just means you’re approach has been systematic” (University of Derby).

How to tell which review type your thesis requires

Work through these in order. The first one that gives a clear answer wins.

  1. Read your handbook and module specification. If the word “systematic” appears in the assessment brief or marking criteria, find out exactly what it asks for. Wrexham Glyndŵr’s MSc dissertation module, for example, offers a systematic literature review route. Its specification says the review “should seek to identify all relevant published and unpublished evidence, select studies or reports for inclusion, assess the quality of each study” (Wrexham Glyndŵr University).
  2. Ask your supervisor one direct question. “Do you expect a search another student could repeat, or a synthesis that argues for my gap?” The answer settles most cases.
  3. Look at your question. If you can list a population, an exposure or intervention and an outcome, and you want every study on it, that points systematic. If you want to explain how a field has thought about something, that points narrative.
  4. Check the time you have. Borah and colleagues looked at 195 completed reviews registered in PROSPERO. They found a mean of 67.3 weeks from start to publication, and a mean of 5 authors per review (Borah et al., 2017). Those were reviews of medical interventions, but the scale is the point: one student in one semester is a different job.

For a dissertation that collects its own data, Lincoln’s guide says the review chapter of a dissertation “is normally a narrative or traditional literature review selecting literature based on judgement” (University of Lincoln).

Three questions for your first supervision meeting

  1. Does the handbook or rubric use the word “systematic”, and what does the department mean by it?
  2. Should my search be reproducible, and do you want the search strings in an appendix?
  3. Does the methodology chapter need a section on how the review was done, or does the review sit outside the method?

Signs you picked the wrong type

  • Your chapter title says “systematic”, but you could not tell a classmate which databases you searched or what you excluded.
  • Your supervisor keeps asking about coverage and you keep answering about argument, or the reverse.
  • You built screening tables for a question your supervisor describes as a discussion.

What a systematic review commits you to

A systematic review fixes the question, the databases, the search strings and the inclusion and exclusion criteria before you start, then records every decision as you screen. A narrative review lets you chase themes and add or drop papers as the argument develops. That flexibility is the narrative review’s strength, and the reason it cannot call itself systematic.

PRISMA 2020 in plain terms

PRISMA 2020 is a guideline for reporting systematic reviews. It has a 27-item checklist and flow diagrams that account for records found, removed and included (Page et al., 2021). Keep a screening log from the first day, so the numbers in your flow diagram match your methods section.

Do you need to register a protocol in PROSPERO

Only if your review fits its rules. PROSPERO “prospectively registers systematic reviews with outcomes of direct relevance to health within humans” (PROSPERO). Its eligibility page lists what it does not accept, including:

  • “Traditional literature reviews that use a systematic search but do not adopt other systematic review methods”;
  • scoping reviews, which “are not currently accepted but may be in future”;
  • systematic reviews that have already started data extraction.

So a structured review in education or history does not go to PROSPERO. Document your search and criteria anyway, because your examiner will still read them.

How to describe your review method in the methodology chapter

Name the approach honestly and describe what you did. Our guide on how to write a methodology chapter covers the wider chapter. These two templates cover the review part.

For a narrative literature review:

Relevant literature was identified through searches of [databases] using combinations of [terms], supplemented by citation chasing from key sources. Sources were selected for their relevance to [framework or question], with priority given to peer-reviewed work published from [year]. Earlier works were included where they define the field. The literature was synthesised thematically around [themes].

For a systematic or systematised review:

This review followed [PRISMA 2020 / the protocol in Appendix X]. [Databases] were searched from [date] to [date] using the strategy in Appendix [X]. Studies were included if [criteria] and excluded if [criteria]. [Number] records were screened by [one reviewer / two reviewers, with disagreements resolved by ...]. [Number] studies met the criteria and were appraised using [tool].

If you used one screener, say so. A structured review with one screener is a legitimate method. A review that implies a second screener who never existed is a problem.

Grey literature searches need the same documented strings as database searches. When you cite reports and theses you found that way, our guide to citing grey literature in APA covers the formats.

What examiners ask about each kind of review

For a narrative review, expect questions about judgement:

  • How did you decide what to read, and what did you leave out on purpose?
  • Where does the field disagree, and where do you stand?
  • Which claims in the review rest on a single source?

For a systematic or systematised review, the tone shifts to audit:

  • Why was this study excluded?
  • Could you rerun the search today and get the same records?
  • Where did you depart from your protocol, and why?

Bring your search log, your exclusion reasons and an honest account of any change of plan. Where the review chapter sits in the thesis as a whole is covered in our PhD thesis structure guide.

Check every reference before the review goes in

Whichever type you write, every source in it has to be real and has to say what you say it says. Resolve each DOI yourself and confirm the authors, title and year match. Check that nothing you cite has been retracted. Our step-by-step guide on how to verify references walks through the free registries and what each result means.

Then keep a short log of what you read in full and what you only skimmed. If a claim rests on a paper you never opened, read it or cut the claim.

What Thesisroom does with this

Which review type to write is a decision for you, your supervisor and your handbook. Thesisroom checks the sources the review rests on. Citation Check draws on nine academic registries. It checks whether each work is in published research databases such as Crossref and OpenAlex, whether the DOI resolves and whether the paper has been retracted (Thesisroom). Retraction status comes partly from Crossref, which carries Retraction Watch’s database on the original work (Thesisroom method).

Frequently asked questions

Can I call my review systematic if I did not write a protocol?Not as a full systematic review. Without a protocol, documented searches and explicit criteria, describe it as a narrative, structured or systematised literature review, and say in your methods what you actually did.
Is a systematic literature review the same as a systematic review?Not always. Oxford’s Bodleian Libraries describe the systematic literature review as a lighter option for master’s projects, drawing on systematic methods but usually with fewer databases and one screener. Check what your department means by the term.
How long does a systematic review take?One study of 195 PROSPERO-registered reviews of medical interventions found a mean of 67.3 weeks to publication, with about five authors per review. Oxford’s Bodleian Libraries say a full systematic review usually takes at least 12 months and two people.
Do I need to register my review in PROSPERO?Only if it is a systematic review with outcomes of direct relevance to human health. PROSPERO does not accept traditional literature reviews that use a systematic search, and it does not currently accept scoping reviews.
Can a master’s dissertation be a systematic review?Some programmes offer it as a route, with requirements set in the module specification. Many master’s students write a systematised or structured review instead, because a full systematic review needs a team and a long timeline.
Is a literature review less rigorous than a systematic review?It answers a different question. A good narrative review is rigorous in its reading and argument. It is weaker on reproducibility, so say clearly how you searched and selected, even when no protocol was required.

Sources

How this guide was made: Thesisroom drafted this guide with the help of AI writing tools. Every fact, figure and source in this post was checked against its original source before publishing.